Music / Idols
20120215_seoulbeats_speed

Not Quite Speeding — Not Yet

31

Truth to be told, Core Contents Media has not quite impressed me with their groups — although recently, T-ara has left their mark. Even so, the girls’ efforts post “Roly Poly” didn’t quite drag me into the fandom, so to this day, I remain an onlooker.

If there is one artist under CCM that I am interested in though, it would be Co-Ed School. Their debut song, “Too Late” wasn’t much of an attention-grabbing song. It had something of a catchiness to it, but the ridiculous application of autotune was certainly a turn-off (and this is coming from somebody who enjoys things techno quite a fair amount). The second title track I stumbled across over my Youtube wanderings was something of an improvement – fun and quirky “Bbiribbom Bberibbom”. It wasn’t enough to make me a fan, but it gave me some kind of hope, because the styling for the single had been so wildly different from their debut and frankly, a lot more appealing, simply because it stood out. And, well, I’d take a multi-coloured hospital ward over the same grunge I’ve seen a hundred times. “I Love You A Thousand Times” was a drastic change, in both image and musical style. It may have not been the best choice for a promotional song, considering the fairly small market for ballads; however, it did its job in impressing me. From then on, I kept an eye on any Co-Ed activities. 5dolls didn’t quite floor me, but they had put out some decent material (the single that caught my eye was “Lip Stains”), so I was hopeful.

Then, I was greeted with news of the male sub-unit of Co-Ed School: SPEED. Like quite a few others, the first thing that came to my head was the legendary Japanese girl group of the same name. Naturally, I dismissed this obscure thought after scrolling down and eyeing the concept photo. After all, this was the male sub-unit that I had been half-waiting for and really, I was quite pleased by the concept photos. Still, I was skeptical. A remake of labelmate T-ara’s “Lovey Dovey”? No new song? The whole concept had me raising question marks along with my eyebrows, but I kept my mouth shut about the whole thing. At least, until the 60-second preview of the remake was released.

And in fact, it was not just one preview, but there was actually a total of two floating around.

Piece those two together (I would if I could be bothered starting up my video editing software on a Sunday night), and you have a fairly decent idea of what the entire song sounds like. And to be completely honest? I actually like SPEED’s remake better. Why? To be frank, T-ara reminds me of KARA in terms of their vocal ability. While there are decent singers in both groups, their voices have a tendency to merge into one extremely high-pitched tone. Whether or not this is something I can attribute to the members’ voices or the songs that CCM grants them — I cannot say due to my relative unfamiliarity with the group. However, that is the conclusion I come to after listening to my fair share of T-ara’s music. It’s something that works great in certain songs, but in the end of the day, there isn’t any way for me to differentiate one voice from another. That, I assure you, isn’t the best scenario. Especially not when there is something about their voices merged together which vaguely reminds me of singing chipmunks. Furthermore, while there wasn’t anything insulting to the ears with the original — in fact, I found the energetic and slightly retro flair in the song rather endearing — SPEED upped the ante with me. The intro was powerful and well-arranged, despite the trademark announcement of their return (which is ironic, considering that this is essentially their debut as a sub-unit) and the near-explosive transition into the chorus had me bopping my head to it.

However, when the official MVs came out, I was incredibly disappointed. Not so much by the quality of the song — that was quite enjoyable. Rather the video itself was a complete turn-off. The second version wasn’t even worth discussing, for SPEED was pretty much non-existent. I knew that I shouldn’t have been looking forward to it too much; after all, the sleek suits, the satisfying audio sample — all of that was just too good to be true, right? Was it only inevitable that the MV would end up a nearly-hot mess? Whether or not the atrocity is completely T-ara’s Hyomin‘s doing is debatable. While she did indeed volunteer to help edit the video, she would most definitely still have been under supervision of some sort. Either way, I was unimpressed by the editing in the music videos. While the styling is indeed slick and completely to my liking, the cuts and flashes of lights most certainly weren’t. I can understand the conceptual direction of it, yes, especially when you consider the swift tempo of the song. However, what irks me is that the entire music video is essentially composed of SPEED and the twins (Hwayoung and Hyoyoung) dancing, coupled with a ridiculously short compilation of individual shots. I could go on a hate-filled rant about how it is essentially a dance video but I won’t, considering that this isn’t SPEED’s official debut.

All in all, while there is nothing about “Lovey Dovey Plus” that tells me about SPEED’s official debut — at least, nothing concrete that CCM has announced — I know that I will be keeping an eye on them regardless. For one, as far as remakes go, they’ve done a fair job with ”Lovey Dovey Plus” and their past releases as Co-Ed School have had their ways in giving me some hope. And really, one poorly-executed release shouldn’t turn away somebody forever. I for one, feel that Co-Ed School (as well as their sub-units) has the potential. I might not have their music on repeat quite yet, but I feel that they’re getting there, bit by bit. After all, 5dolls did secure an unlikely spot in my iTunes library with their debut mini album — there’s no reason why SPEED might not do the same.

(LOENENT, Osen)

Related Posts

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1126983493 Alice Batcheldor

    I think I might have a brain aneurism if I watch any more of the ridiculous flashing. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/KFOLAJLXYHOCHDRFCSECACDGFI Lisuh-chan

    the music videos were horrible. I liked the remake ver. of the song tho. Even though I believed that SPEED deserved their own song as a debut, I seriously loved the beginning intro (bass) of the loveydovey plus. There’s not much to say, but I’ll make sure to keep an eye on them when they finally release material made initially for them and make their real “official” debut.

  • Anonymous

    As a casual fan of T-ara and a bias to member So Yeon (yes, I just love women that can sing), I’d put this as both right and wrong. Yes, it is debatable whether if Hyomin can be completely blamed but then again, I don’t think she’s ever had any real experience in editing music videos or any of the such (not even in her trainee days in JYP) - the possibility that she only did a portion of it whilst under supervision is higher, of course.

    Regarding their singing talents…well, they actually did start out pretty well with decent songs back in their early months (TTL, Good Person, Lies, for starters). But then again, CCM is run by a faggot called Kim Kwang Su – who’s more concerned with money in his pockets than giving the group decent music to perform on stage – which goes to say, stuff like Roly Poly, Bo Peep Bo Peep, YaYaYa (an atrocity comparable to Rebecca Black’s Friday), Lovey Dovey etc. aren’t exactly songs that are easy to perform live, added by the physically demanding choreography and the well…electronic/techno (or whatever you call it) nature of the songs.

    The fact they’re overworked (apparently only an average of 2-3 hours of sleep a day) makes things worse in live performances, not to mention members like Qri, Boram and Jiyeon are awfully lackluster (and to put it at worst, simply atrocious) in singing while Hwayoung serves very little purpose to the group - this may also explain why the back music in their live performances is also rather loud and makes it difficult to hear out their actual singing, regardless if the more better vocals in the group can pull it off. Why they seem like KARA to you, I’ll never understand.

    Personally, I don’t really see a reason to remake the song but given the uninteresting nature of it, well, I’ll leave it at that. Though I’m more concerned that CCM might screw this up - their level of management isn’t exactly the greatest (hell, look what went with Co-Ed). I’ll agree with you that Roly Poly wasn’t much of an attention grab - though to me, it was more like a homage to the youth generation whose college years were in the 80s, the height of South Korea’s economic rise – this is what my mother also agreed with, considering she was in college back then too and the music reminded her of those times (of course, the song didn’t do so much justice with T-ara’s more vocally talented members).   

    • Anonymous

      Excellent comment except for the “faggot” remark. Let’s leave the hateful words to kindergarteners and people who don’t know any better. Plus the last time I checked KKS wasn’t a cigarette, a bundle of sticks, or a gay man. He is a bit incompetent, though.

      • Anonymous

        I apologize if it was of any inconvenience. Normally I don’t call people faggots, but KKS is an exception. He’s more than just a ‘bit incompetent’.

        Aside from poor management and not making full use of T-ara’s talents and potential, he hasn’t even given them even a single vacation since their debut and not a single day of rest ever since Roly Poly was released – something not even the bulk of T-ara’s fans are probably even aware of because they’re too busy obsessing over the group or spamming/scream-typing out the name of their favorite member in the internet, and that’s putting it in a very general way. Hell, even SM gives their idols a break every now and then.

        Furthermore, when KARA had their contract issues with DSP a while back, Kim even commented in an interview that some of the members shouldn’t bother being in the entertainment industry at all (whilst also getting involved with it one way or another, the info ain’t hard to search for).

        Either way, he’s despicable, regardless of the fact he’s pushed T-ara to immense popularity since last summer.

         

        • Anonymous

          it doesn’t matter if he is the worst person in the world there’s no reason to use hurtful slurs like that. Being gay and being incompetent have nothing to do with each other.

          • Anonymous

            I wasn’t intentionally calling him as gay, but regardless, he deserves much criticism, rightfully so. I’m merely expressing my opinion regarding him. 

        • http://twitter.com/Sphinx201 Quốc Anh

          entertainment industry is tough he has saved KARA

           remember JYJ

          • Anonymous

            He never did anything to ‘save’ KARA, considering KARA was under DSP, not Core Contents Media. Get your facts right. In fact, he had little to no right to interfere with the contract issue and abused his power in the entertainment industry.  

            If he said that they shouldn’t even be in the entertainment industry while also boycotting the YPA’s support for KARA in regards to DSP’s poor treatment of the group, how is that ‘saving’ them, hm? I’d be fully enlightened to hear your explanation on that matter.

            Nor did he do anything for JYJ.

          • http://twitter.com/Sphinx201 Quốc Anh

            naive questions 

            Good deed, bad precedent  :)

          • Anonymous

            Obviously you don’t have anything to say in the matter, nor do you even have in-depth knowledge of anything surrounding KKS, yet alone any of the shady parts of the K-pop industry in total. 

            I’m sorry to say, but you’re giving me the impression that simply nothing more than a delusional fan (boy or girl, I won’t bother to care) or a troll. 

  • Anonymous

    “ Why? To be frank, T-ara reminds me of KARA in terms of their vocal ability. While there are decent singers in both groups, their voices have a tendency to merge into one extremely high-pitched tone.”

    Argh, I try to avoid doing the butthurt fan thing but seriously are you freakin kidding me? I mean are you joking?  While I agree this is true for their promoted hook songs which don’t show their abilities at all , T-ara is a lot more talented than you give tham credit for.  Have you even heard of any of their other songs. I mean really?! If you are going to make a comment like that at least take the time to listen to their B-sides and other non promoted material because frankly speaking that comment is a bit ignorant. I like both groups but lets be real here, KARA is highly lacking in the vocal department with all of the decent singers only really able to sing in the high register.  T-ara on the other hand has three really good vocalists with rich vocal tones.  I mean Soyeon alone has probably one of the best voices and vocal control out of kpop girl groups. Hyomin and Eunjung are really good singers but often relegated to rapping since they are capable at it as well.  Boram and Jiyeon are on par with KARA I will agree to that and I honestly don’t see the point of Hwayoung and Qri. 

    Eunjungs parts from Absolute (I have no idea how a fan found the time to do this)

    her and soo hyun for spris

    Hyomin’s Singing

    Soyeon’s Singing

    Boram (shes sick here too)

    Jiyeon’s Singing

    • Anonymous

      I think what she meant is that in their songs overall, they are so autotuned (yes, they may be able to sing but it doesn’t stop their company to hide that ability) that in the end, they all sound the same.

      I cannot for one listen to a T-ara song and make out who is singing what. And having clicked on a few of the links you’ve shown, that’s a shame.

      • http://twitter.com/Sphinx201 Quốc Anh

        Cry Cry, Lies, TTL 2, WWIL……

        • Anonymous

          Their voices still sound quite similar… It’s a problem you encounter in most girl groups though (most, not all, I can distinguish BEG’s voices pretty well but then again there are only vocalists so that makes it easier)

          • http://twitter.com/Sphinx201 Quốc Anh

            your problem is underestimated everything

            one thing : listen to their album then apologize for your ignorance. Their title songs are catchy, their album tracks are pure wonders.

          • Anonymous

            Oops I meant to say 4 vocalists, not just vocalists.

            And hey, I’m entitled to my own opinions :) Why should I apologise for my “ignorance”?

          • Anonymous

            He/She is a delusional fan in the level of Super Saiyan, as pointed in one particular article in this site.

            Those kinda fans will defend their idols up to the point of fanaticism and sadly, they do more harm than good. They can’t stand even one tiny bit of constructive criticism (in fact, constructive criticism probably never even exists as anything in their deluded brains lol). This is coming from a casual T-ara fan.

    • Anonymous

      Even as a casual fan of T-ara, I don’t see why you seem to think Jiyeon and Boram are good at singing – sure, maybe they’re somewhat able to, but their range is rather quite limited. Jiyeon has yet to perform any of her OSTs live, despite being fairly popular, for starters. Even KARA’s Seungyeon can sing better than either, admittedly. But even so, comparing the two groups is like comparing apples and oranges.

      I don’t know about Boram’s schedule but Jiyeon’s one likely leaves very little room to properly practice on singing, given that she’s awfully busy with dramas, variety shows, live performances, commercial shoots etc. (hell, she’s probably THE most overworked member of the group, arguably).

      Agreed that Hyomin, Soyeon and Eunjung are the more vocally talented of the group, tops. All three of them did after all, have extensive training as trainees (unlike Boram and Qri, who were added in only a MONTH before debut and Hwayoung remains a complete mystery).

      • http://twitter.com/Sphinx201 Quốc Anh

        jiyeon vocal maybe not powerfull like other but her voice are unique.. no matter how many voice i listen singing in this world,i still said my choice is “park jiyeon”
        voice.. melt my heart.. i’m touched with her soft husky voice.. :)

        • Anonymous

          How is it ‘unique’ hm? You’re obviously a Jiyeon-stan aka a fangirl (or fanboy) in Super Saiyan level, as noted by one particular article that addresses that.

          Sure, you’re welcome to say Jiyeon is the best – in YOUR world. Regardless, her range is limited and just because her voice is ‘unique’ doesn’t mean she’s a good singer. From your logic, then George Bush should be a ‘unique’ president simply because he started two wars in his presidency.

          Soyeon, Eunjung and Hyomin are better vocalists than Jiyeon by all means, and that is a F-A-C-T.  

      • Anonymous

        I don’t think Jiyeon and Boram are great singers, far from it, but I don’t think they are horrendous as people make them out to be. They just have voices in the softer registers. Many people make it seem like they are absolute tone deaf which isn’t the case. They can sing especially Boram who happens to have a really nice tone to her voice. Yes both of them have very limited range but when they do sing in the range appropriate for their voices they sound really nice. Frankly instead of idoldom I think Boram should of gone the indie route because I think her voice has a tone that would work quite nicely with acoustic instruments.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t have much to say except that the REMAKE IS SO MUCH BETTER (music-wise). So nice to listen to fuller voices than the thin, little-girl “lovey dovey oh oh oh oh.”

  • Anonymous

    I like the outfits and dancing… reminds me strongly of debut INFINITE (because it was michael jackson inspired too). I like the song too… a lot actually except for the fact that it doesn’t go anywhere but the mv is AWFUL. Boring, shaky and all over the place.

    I wasn’t a fan of T-ara’s lovey-dovey but this made me like the song somewhat lol.

  • Kristopher Roberson

    I feel like im the only one that doesnt like this remake. The rapping is great but the production itself just sounds like a bunch of noise to me. I’ll what for their own songs to make a judgement but i hope to god they dont overproduce that too.

    • Anonymous

      You’re not the only one. I found this remake terrible. And I’m generally one to love remakes.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lonesome-Dove/1431078572 Lonesome Dove

    heard a lot of negative feedback concerning this song and vid but personally I like it a lot keep playing it over and over again and this is coming from someone who does not care for kpop and k idols I liked coed school and I like speed nothing special musically for sure but then again I dont find any korean idol band to be impressive musically… concerning the video even with the crappy editing I find it better than the usual cheesy over the top concept of most korean boy bands MVs

  • Anonymous

    I share your feelings regarding CCM: I am still not a fan, although lately T-ara has been growing on me and it was a pleasant experience seeing them in Paris.

    But I disagree with you on SPEED’s remake. It was a huge disappointment to me. I enjoyed Lovey Dovey as a refreshing dance club song, and as a well-executed mixture between the flowery side of K-pop and the excess of shuffling (although I admit, it’s not a song for everybody’s tastes). And when I enjoy a song (especially a song that I still believe there’s a room for improvement), I also tend to enjoy remakes even more.

    But this wasn’t the case. First, the background music sounds like an odd mixture between trance beats and the kind of music you’d ear in dodgem tracks [is that how you say in English?]. I’d said this is the cheap result after playing with Windows Media Player a few hours. Also, the rhythm of the music seems sometimes going off-track, as it evolves independently of their singing, sometimes overlapping their voices. There are parts of the music that literally sound like a bunch of noise, and I’m pretty sure it wasn’t the producers’ intention. Overall, it looks like a mess, and sounds like a mess to me. While I agree that SPEED’s voices sound better, the overuse of rap added to this huge electronic annoyance tires my ears, and ironically, makes me prefer the high-pitched tone of T-ara’s singing, as I feel it merges better with the consistency of the sound.

    The MV is even worse than the song itself, mostly for reasons you already stated. I guess they are using T-ara’s Lovey Dovey success to promote this new subgroup, but the execution was terrible. They could as well turn Lovey Dovey into a ballad, or give a more manly feeling to the song by inserting some hard electronic or industrial sounds, but in the end they only managed to produce yet another generic dance song, but weaker than the original.

    • Anonymous

      The song failed to interest me at all, and this is coming from a T-ara fan. Lol.

      Why CCM thought they should remake Lovey Dovey for another group is beyond me. The whole idea seemed unnecessary at best and at worst, a waste of time as if CCM couldn’t be bothered to produce something else.

      On the side note, T-ara hasn’t been able to sing Lovey Dovey on live so well – the high-pitched tone of the song itself is rather difficult to perform, not to mention the dance itself doesn’t look very easy to perform either (along with Qri and Boram’s….low singing ability and everyone else getting just 2-3 hours of sleep a day). I’ll agree it was well-executed as a fresh dance club song – hell, I even listen to it while going for an evening run. Not bad to listen to when you need to cheer up from feeling all gloomy and bored.

      SPEED’s remake? Didn’t have that effect at all.

      • Anonymous

        Yes, I also think the high-pitched tone is the real problem of Lovey Dovey (and the main aspect I wished to see improved in this remake, but the rap ended up being equally irritating). I noticed that too in Paris. But I truly enjoyed watching Lovey Dovey live, the rest of their performance was a bit boring to me.
        Anyway, my favorite of T-ara is still Cry Cry.

        • Anonymous

          Agreed on your words. Hm, one thing I catched was that Lovey Dovey’s live performances while rather not so done well, at the least they made themselves look…I don’t know, flashy in the fashion sense?

          Cry Cry is my favorite as well (at least until T-ara has something better to show in the future) – it was a damn good close redemption to the stuff they released in their earlier months.