• http://profile.yahoo.com/R5BKARJWK7NNOXYOIUSP76YJW4 Aj

    I dont know anyone from this group actually and never really cared but this song blew me away.I’m their new fan.

  • http://twitter.com/dewaanifordrama dewaanifordrama

    Couldn’t agree more!

  • Streby

    The styling is really chic and I love the smooth transitions between happy and sad, it is a very nice portrayal of love; when one is in love, everything seems like a magical garden and when the love dies everything seems dead, dark and despairing. 

  • AcadiasFire

    I just think b1a4 is excellent overall but they blew me away with this album. It’s completely beautiful

  • http://twitter.com/M_Wys Michaela Wylie

    More B1A4 spazz time!!! ^_^

    “the other members are free to simply add to the overall visual appeal of the MV and subtly emote to compliment the feeling of the song”
    Totes not true. All the members are really solid singers, tbh. We should give credit where it’s due. :)

    Or, since there wasn’t much CNU and Gongchan, at least Jinyoung. His voice was quite prominent in the song, I thought. Maybe because he composed it and all? I don’t know, seems like a silly reason, but I feel like he might be emotionally attached to this song, possibly because it’s really his best work so far. 

    Anyways, I realized the only English word in the song is “baby” or something. Lol. XD

    Can we discuss the key change in the song? Omg, it was perfect. Like…the build-up was freaking perfect. I think that’s what really brought this song up from good to great. That extra emphasis really just makes the song so much better for me. :)

    Oh, and does anyone else this that the giant-bone-world looks like the elephant graveyard from “The Lion King”? Because I do. That’s all I can think of when I watch it. >_<

    • black_rose45000

      Not to sound like a hater or a troll, but please guide me to something that proves Gongchan’s singing ability. Because from what I’ve listened so far…:S And he seems to get the most forgettable parts in songs too. I almost squealed when I saw he had a couple of solo lines in I only learned bad things.
      Then again, if their promotion performances would’ve been my first exposure to them, instead of Immortal Song, I would’ve singled CNU out from the list-of-solid-singers too >.>

      • http://twitter.com/M_Wys Michaela Wylie

        I would say that Gongchan’s definitely the worst singer (actually…I don’t know if Baro can sing, but I don’t think it matters) in the group, but from the MR Removed videos I’ve seen, he’s solid. 

    • http://twitter.com/L_Mousse Lindsay

      I am sorry I made it sound like I think CNU and Gongchan and Jinyoung aren’t talented in general, that wasn’t my intention at all! 

      I was simply referring to this MV specifically, where they play a more minor role in the actual video. For a more specific analysis of the song itself, instead of the MV, you should check out Seoulbeat’s review of the album. :) Thank you for commenting, and yes, the bone area does look like the elephant graveyard from Lion King!

      • http://twitter.com/M_Wys Michaela Wylie

        Hm. Maybe I was thrown off because Sanduel wasn’t included with the three, so I thought he was being included with Baro as the main focus, which would be weird because he wasn’t the focus visually. Anyways, I’m mixing up my thoughts now, so sorry, and thanks for the suggestion. :)

  • black_rose45000

    Wow so much B1A4 love these days on SB. I’m loving it.
    I watched the video some couple of hrs ago, then I ended up watching more of their pvs and stuff. It’s the first time I’m thoroughly checking an idol group like this since SJ, last year. I hope they don’t end up disappointing me like SJ, or like any other K-pop rookie group who has failed to impress me. >.>
    That aside, I love this video and all the symbolism. 
    I agree with this ” I felt heartbroken just watching him”, I had goosebumps all over during those scenes. The settings and landscapes seem surreal. I love this video ♥
    And your review was great, it helped me spot a few things I’d missed :)

  • http://twitter.com/Dilya_ELF dilya’

    He is Sandeul xD

  • http://twitter.com/Dilya_ELF dilya’

    He is Sandeul xD

  • ArielLM13

    Much love to B1A4. It’s really nice how they grew with their sound so closely.