Music / Idols
20111224_seoulbeats_taemin2

Taemin on Immortal Song: Why People Need to Relax

59
Written by On December 27, 2011

‘Immortal Song 2′, we’ve all heard of it haven’t we? It’s the ever anticipated variety show, where different singers compete against each other to see who can reenact a classic tune the best. It’s a fierce competition which blurs the line between ‘singer’ and ‘performer’, as different talents come together to win and compete for the prize of… their own personal satisfaction, I guess. But most of all, let’s not lie, it’s fun seeing different idols try and outdo each other — it’s basically like the idol version of ‘I Am A Singer‘. But throughout its run, different idols and personalities have had their turn in the spotlight, and it’s line-up is changed every other minute.

The newest additions to the lineup? Brown Eyed Soul‘s Sunghoon, and SHINee‘s Taemin.

When I read the news, I was ridiculously happy. Despite being tied for my least favourite member of SHINee, Taemin is also my favourite vocalist in the group, and even though I still have recurring dreams of him killing me while I sleep, I find the colour of his voice sweet and beautiful. I could only imagine that Shawols would be jumping out of their seats at the news, because their precious maknae finally has an opportunity to really show off his voice. However, looking at the comments, this seems to be far from the case. And instead there’s a general reaction of ‘lol… wut’ going around. Some people are more outraged than others, and the majority seem to scoff at the idea of Taemin guesting on any singing show that’s not having a dance special.

From what I’m observing, there are three main arguments against Taemin and his future stint on the show.

Taemin isn’t a good singer: I understand that despite my love for his voice, Taemin is not the best singer in the band. Up until recently to be honest, he wasn’t even promoted as a singer, but a dancer. Which is one of the reasons I believe, that people undermine the boy’s vocal prowess to an extent that it is almost insulting. I understand that Taemin debuted as the second worst singer in the SHINee– after all, he was barely fifteen and was still growing into his voice. But the boy has come such a long way from debut until now, and people refuse to believe how far he has actually come. Yes, there’s a gap when you compare Taemin’s vocal prowess with Jonghyun and Onew, but that gap is nowhere near as large as the one between Taemin and a ‘mediocre’ singer. Although he’s in a band like SHINee where relatively he’s ‘weak’, the boy can sing. And he can sing well. He has raw talent, and raw talent doesn’t necessarily mean you’re a powerhouse vocalist. But it means you’re born with a voice that has the potential to be molded into one fit for a good singer– Taemin has such potential and even more. And he’s certainly not the worst vocalist to have joined Immortal Song 2 (no offence).


He’s going to get pummeled by other powerhouse vocalists, how embarassing!: This is a legitimate reason, and I understand why fans are concerned. But Immortal Song is a great place for learning! The show does not test a singer on their vocal prowess, but they test a singer on their flexibility and ability to perform and make a song their own. Admittedly the show’s first line-ups were pretty intense, since almost every singer on there reached the heavens and above; Hyorin, Changmin (2AM), Hongki, Yesung, Jonghyun, Yoseob, Jieun and IU. 

Throughout the show, singers left, and singers were added. And to me, that’s when the real potential of the program started showing. And it dawned on me that this show wasn’t about who was the best singer, but who could adapt and intrigue an audience the best. I didn’t realise it immediately, since during the first line-up everyone was fabulous (some more than others of course, but in general they went above and beyond). But later on it became clear. How else did Jay Park and Jiyoon beat out the likes of bombs such as Kyuhyun, G.O, and Hyorin?

Immortal Song is about growth, the singers on the show learn to step out of their shells and really, it’s a performance contest more than a singing contest. They choose the contestants based on vocal prowess when casting, but then test them beyond that. Kyuhyun didn’t get his first win until he let go of his dignity, ditched those ballads, and instead embraced the guyliner and rocked out. That was a big stepping stone, not for Kyuhyun the ‘singer’, but Kyuhyun the ‘performer’. Jiyoon and Jay Park both grew as well, they were forced to be compared to these amazing voices, and you can tell that they really stepped up. Jiyoon who’s always been rough around the edges, really shaped up with her technique, especially since she put in great practice before each of her solo stages. To be honest, I’m a bit sad that their runs ended so quickly, because all of those singers on the show had the potential to become so much more. This show has the potential to be a huge step for Taemin. He may have flaws as a singer, but week after week he will be forced to confront his flaws and perform his heart out.

Plus, the show is not mean. They aren’t going to isolate Taemin if his vocals are not up to par with people like ALi or Sunghoon. The thing I love about Immortal Song is that pre-determined knowledge and prejudice about the contestant’s vocal skills are set aside, and everyone is put on the same level. When the show does hand out criticism, it is done in tact and not embarrassing at all. The previous contestants didn’t spend their spare time thinking about how inferior the others were, they spent their spare time chatting to each other on twitter. This won’t only be a chance for Taemin to grow as a singer and performer, but also a chance to chat up some other vocalists and nice noonas. Go get ‘em, tiger!

It should have been Onew: If you had told me three years ago that I would be taking the side of my least favourite member Taemin, over my own bias Onew, I would have laughed at your face and told you to go home. But three years later and, is this really happening? I love Onew deeply and dearly, but if anyone deserves a chance in the vocal limelight for once, it is Taemin. As I mentioned before, the boy is pushed as the dancer so much, that there’s a large number of people who don’t even think he can sing. This is a chance for him to step out of the type he is boxed in and show everyone his true potential.

I loved all the singers who were on the show. But after thinking about it for a bit, the ones who really reaped the most benefit out of Immortal Song, were those who were not widely known to be good singers, or those powerhouse vocalists that had yet to reach mainstream appeal. I have ALi’s new album playing as background music, and I would never have appreciated her had she not been on the show. And I mean, how many people jumped on the ‘Hyorin must go solo’ bandwagon after watching her cute little head out-sing other idols?

Of course, I’m not comparing Taemin to the likes of Hyorin. But Immortal Song 2 once stated that it’s out there to disprove the theory that idols are ’3-second singers’. And to be honest, it didn’t really do a good job of it the first time around, when they just pitted all those great voices against each other. Everyone knew Kyuhyun, G.O, Yesung, Jonghyun, Hyorin, Junsu ect. could sing. None of them are put under the same assumptions and scrutiny a lot of other talented idols are put under by the public. However, for someone like Jiyoon, who hailed from 4Minute (AKA: ‘Hyuna and the pussycats’), a group which has to have some of the most obnoxious singles ever, Immortal Song 2 became an opportunity for non-fans to blink and go ‘oh hey, 4Minute has a decent singer’. Even though she was outdone by more powerful vocalists, she still gained an appreciation because prior to her stint, nobody was really aware that anyone in 4Minute aside from Gayoon (who’s promoted as the main vocal) knew how to hold a melody.

Likewise, everybody knows Onew can sing. His vocal prowes is never doubted, everyone appreciates him. A lot of people even consider him to be a better singer than Jonghyun due to his deeper voice. But Taemin? People go as far as to put him on the same par as Minho. And honestly, everyone’s talking about what a joke Immortal Song is and how they’ve lot respect for the show — but I’m only beginning to appreciate it for what it’s doing.

So yes, I’m glad it’s Taemin being put on the show over Onew. Immortal Song 2 is a chance for idols to show that they can sing, and it’s a chance for idols to grow, it’s a chance for idols to show that they aren’t just the ‘pretty faces’ or ‘dance machines’ which they’re being type-casted as.

And you know what? Heck, why stop at Taemin? Since Junsu has had his shot, why not put Junho or Wooyoung on the show! Taeyeon has gotten her (much well-deserved) dues already, so cast Seohyun, Tiffany, and maybe even Sunny! Yoseob is always fantastic, but let Hyunseung or Kikwang do their thing!  We already know KRY are awesome, give Sungmin and Donghae a chance in the vocal limelight! Yes, they all have things to work on, some more than others. but they are all talented. And Immortal Song is a great way for them to gain some exposure, face their faults, gain a lifetime worth of invaluable experience, and most importantly, gain some credit for what they’re meant to be  – singers.

(KBS2TV, en.korea.com, Sport Korea)

Related Posts

TAGS: , , , , , , , ,
  • Anonymous

    Been waiting for this, Ree! :)

    I have to admit, my first thought was also, “Why not Onew?” But then again, everyone already know that Onew can sing, and Taemin deserves a chance to show that he’s improving, standing on that stage all alone, not being overshadowed by his hyungs.

    I was worried too about how people would react if Taemin didn’t deliver. How harsh netizens can be, how people would laugh at him, etc etc, but hey, as long as he try his hardest (and we all know that he’s one hardworker), he will improve a lot (hopefully) and people will notice that.

    My secret hope: was wishing that it was Key instead. The boy needs a reminder of his own talent instead of pushing his diva attitude all the time.

    • maldita

      I would love for Key to get back into real singing. He can’t keep doing Kesha/Lady Gaga/Black Eyed Peas covers for the rest of his idol life. I miss hearing him sing like he did in their awesome first album.

      • Anonymous

        He was a good singer in their first album, although he had some problems hitting high notes (I think he struggled a lot with Romantic). But starting from Lucifer, it only went downhill. I hope he gets to sing again in their Korean comeback, but I won’t hope much :(

    • Sueannho92

      I share your secret wish. Watching recent fancams made me realise how ‘lazy’ a singer he recently became. What happened to the smooth voice in the first album? I miss the vocals he had during the ’08 years (that live performance of Romantic(!)) He should really step up his game in the vocal department and realise that attitude just isn’t going to cut it. (Hopefully he isn’t smoking or doing something damaging to his voice ‘cos this ‘path’ he’s going through strangely reminds me of Micky Yoochun..)

      • http://twitter.com/PheonixiaJJ Echo

        I’m sorry for replying to your comment with this….but I am tired of the jabs against Yoochun.  He can still hold his own.  He is not a weak singer.

        • Anonymous

           As much as I like Yoochun, (and I’m sure Sueannho92 likes him as well) there’s no denying that the quality of his voice has deteriorated since 2008. Asthma’s not an excuse (I sing and I have asthma) and his cigarette smoking is only compounding the problem. It’s true that JYJ writes songs to suit Jae and Junsu more, but that’s not a reason for Yoochun to allow his vocals to take a back seat just because he doesn’t have his old role of balancing Yunho’s bass and Junsu’s tenor (therefore balancing the group dynamic as a whole).

          • Anonymous

            i have to agreed with echo, i am getting tired of the jabs too.

            yes, i know his voice doesn’t sound the same but the way ppl keep jabbing against yoochun… u think he can’t sing anymore or has become the worst singer in kpop.

            yes, his voice is not as awesome as he had it in 08 but he can still sing and pretty damn good compare to some of the acts out right now.

        • Anonymous

          pfft 
          dont point that out and the fact that he was singing in sub zero temperatures
          shhhhh  :/
          everybody has way too much fun trying to convince themselves he’s crap
          Yoochun gets the most band wagon hate,

      • Anonymous

        What made me even sadder is the fact that his dancing has been deteriorating as well. Compared to their debut days, when Key can easily outdance Taemin, the standard of Key’s recent dancing is so low. I really don’t mind him embracing the diva attitude, cause that’s Key, but he can’t rely on that personality forever. 

  • Anonymous

    I was going to throw a “lol… wut” comment before I read the full article. Haha. Nice one. I agree with Jiyoon’s improvement though. I know she’s not par up to Hyorin or ALi, but her “Nan” stage still left a very deep impression for me. 

    The thing with Taemin is, I never underestimate his vocal, but his stage presence isn’t as strong as Jonghyun or Onew, imo. I haven’t watched SHINee stages for so long so I don’t really know whether he has improved not. What I watched from the past SHINee stages is he does look earnest and hardworking, but I always feel he’s more to the “weaker part of SHINee”. 

    But anyway, it’s a good thing that “Immortal Song 2″ isn’t a mere ballad showdown, so Taemin can try various songs and improve himself. After all, he looks diligent and quiet ambitious, so who knows? I’m a bit pessimist about Jiyoon participating in “Immortal Song 2″ before, but if she managed to snatch #1 spot… why can’t Taemin? Heck, I even think Han Sunhwa from Secret or Hoya from Infinite can try this show as well. xD

    • maldita

      THIS. Taemin has amazing stage presence when dancing because he knows he’s good at it. However, he seriously has confidence issues when it comes to singing, and it shows whenever he gets to sing more than he usually does. When Taemin first started subbing for Jonghyun, he hits the notes just like he should but he looks so nervous, it just doesn’t give justice to his singing. Admittedly, he’s gotten better, so him being on the show would do wonders for his confidence if he takes full advantage of it.

      • Anonymous

        Yes, “confidence”, you put it into a better word, hehe. At least Key, while his voice often cracks and he’s kinda half-assed these days, is comfortable with himself and keep the stage dynamic.

  • Anima

     I don’t think Onew shouldn’t have been either but only because the ratings are really low on that show right now and tbh, no shinee member needs is2. But I do think that shinee stans underestimate Onew because most comments in regards to shinee nowadays during performances are about Jonghyun which is sad imo because of the two, as someone who sings I can say that Onew is in fact the better singer now that he has improved (his snowflower cover is amazing)… but whatever, at the end of the day I see Onew having the most successful post-shinee career because the public prefers him and his voice anyways. Every shinee jingle or group feature is always Onew heavy. Sorry I had to let that out since Onew was mentioned and people always acknowledge his talent but overlook it :( 

    Now as for Taemin, SM has been pimping this boy out recently and I get the feeling that they have plans/ ulterior motives for him which is why they are putting him on IS2 tbh. His voice is so lovely though, it reminds me of Jaejoong with a hint of non-oversinging Jonghyun but original at the same time. It’s obvious that Taemin has more passion for dancing/ composition (piano), if they hone those skills… Taemin could have a bright future, but I get the feeling that sm is just looking at short term success and a quick  maximized dollar with this boy.

    Key and Minho are the ones who really need an opportunity of some sort imo, especially Key. When Shinee is over, what will they have? Key has done almost nothing outside of Shinee and even within shinee, he’s not particularly fantastic at anything tbh, his singing lacks passion and his dancing is good but only when he cares. Minho… his voice is SO beautiful tbh, if he trained it, I think he’d be better than Taemin. Him and Onew have the nicest sounding voices in Shinee… too bad he rarely has the chance to show it because he’s a designated rapper and fails at it so people think he has no talent… his line in to your heart is best thing about that song tbh.

    • Ilovemandoo

      Omg Minho.. so true. His voice is quite lovely, but they desperately need to train him! He won’t ever be a powerhouse, but if his talents were developed, he would definitely be a decent singer. 

      Similarly, this was the case for Taemin not so long ago, but SM finally gave him voice lessons. (They didn’t give him lessons pre-debut because his voice was still changing :( It’s quite unfortunate because that’s where this idea that ‘he can’t sing’ got started. I recall that he was also upset because he wanted to improve but he wasn’t getting the training. )

      Anyway, I’m very excited to see Taemin on the show. He’s quite ambitious and competitive in his own way. Hopefully, he’ll do well and be receptive to feedback, which I think he already is.

  • Anonymous

    I am actually glad Taemin is put on the show because when immortal song originally was talked about I thought it was going to have idol singers like Taemin who people originally believed couldn’t sing prove otherwise. I mean I like changmin, hyorin, youngjae, kyuhyun , etc. but I already knew they were powerhouse vocalists as did most of korea so it wasnt a surprise thr they could sing. I wished they had people like taemin, sunny, donghae,zinger, dal shabets subin, hoya, amber, or sistar’s soyu or dasom on the show. I mean soyu has an amazing voice but because hyorinn is always highlighted many people think she cannot sing.

  • Anonymous

    Agree 100%. The show shouldn’t be about promoting the best of the best in idol/non idol-dom and it shouldn’t be a contest of who can hit the highest and lowest notes or do the most [obnoxious] melismas and ad-libs in a verse. It should be about singers stepping out of their comfort zones and getting the chance to learn and improve. There’s signature sounds, moves, and gestures that all singers have that makes them good. A good singer and performer knows how to take what they’re already good at and transfer it to a different medium. Nothing is more boring and monotonous than a one trick pony who can’t convincingly switch their delivery and style to accommodate to different audiences. Every singer isn’t suited to every genre, but every singer should at least be able to switch back and forth between 2-3 different styles like say… Pop, Rock, R&B, Ballad, Jazz, etc. just to name a few.

    As much as people bow down to Onew, Jonghyun, and other idols known for their golden pipes (I admit, I do my share of bowing now and then as well), the weaker singers are really the ones we should be building up from the ground. It’s usually (not always) the ones with the most worship given who disappoint us in the end and the ones left standing are usually the ones everyone doubted. Remember the 90′s? Remember Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey? Everyone was eargasming all over their voices and hated on less vocally gifted artists. Where are they now? Whitney’s still trying to sing with her non existent post cigarettes, marijuana, and crack voice and non existent technique. Mariah can’t sing above a whisper now. The ones everyone doubted: Britney, Janet, Rihanna, etc. still have their voices left, have been improving, and are still creating records.

    The vocalists who don’t debut with their voices being top notch like Taemin, Dara, Sohee, Minho, etc. as far as pitch control, confidence, and roles suited to them concerned are the ones who work the hardest. They’re the ones who know they’re not up to snuff. People may say they don’t have the (vocal/stage) power to go solo, but they’re not like the SNSDs, Mickys, Jonghyuns, and Keys of the Kpop scene who have been told that they’re perfect in everything they do and because of their egos, bad habits/attitudes, and fan enabling, they allow their performance to suffer.

    Immortal Song should continue what they’re doing. It will only benefit and encourage the ones like Taemin, Minho, Key, Sohee, Hara, Dara, etc. (as well as the singers who are already known for their prowess) and therefore improve their respective groups and possible solo careers in the long run.

    • chelle

      Okay……since when did Britney and Rihanna improve?? Have you seen Briteny live now she is way past her prime and can’t even muster 1% of her stage presence pre-bald phase. She’s relevant but she digressed….a lot. the difference between her concerts in I’m a slave for you (and below) to her more recent is huge, in a bad way. Rihanna….just no the girl has no presence and her vocals are still average (just look at her grammy performance with eminem) but has catchy songs.

      • Anonymous

        Did I say Britney and Rihanna were actually good? I’ll put it this way: you’ll never find them on my mp3 players. I’ll leave it at that, though I find Rihanna more tolerable. Besides, their relevancy has nothing to do with how good they are (esp. on stage). Rihanna’s company gives her good chart hits [most of the time], Britney has her longevity from sticking around past the mental breakdowns and 90′s pop princess bubble bust to fall back on. But that’s beside the point.

        The point is this: no matter how bad/good/average they are in some respects, they still have careers. Whether we like that fact or not, that’s what matters in the long run.

  • Anonymous

    Another thing I’m excited about is that Immortal Song 2 brings out the musicality and composer persona in these artists. They essentially re-make old songs, right? Judging from the idols who did well in the show, they were those who invested themselves in the music, immersed themselves in the production of the song and are naturally heading towards the singer/songwriter path. Hyorin, Junsu, Changmin, GO, Jay Park and Huh Gak – I think it were these guys who really did the hard work and contributed to their production numbers. Heck, Junsu was even taking charge of re-arranging his songs (together with One Way’s Chance ofc and it was freakin brilliant!) 

    As viewers, we got to know more about them as artists, their musicality and individual tastes. In this sense, I am most excited about seeing what Taemin can bring to the table. Admittedly, I only know him as SHINee’s noona bait and monster dancer so I’d love for him to break out of that stereotype and communicate his own taste and flair in music. 

  • Anonymous

    I agree, putting Taemin on the show starts to bring back the show’s original purpose: disprove 3-second singers and give others a chance for the limelight. I never had any remote intrest in Sistar, but at least now I’ve gained an appreciation for Hyorin. We don’t need Onew on the show (although he’s my favorite), he’s already done musicals and solo stages. We know he can sing. But this is good exposure for Taemin. For some reason, if you are promoted as the “dancer” or “singer,” you can only be one. It’s so hard for people to accept that they might be both. This is also a good place for Taemin to learn. I feel like he copies his group member’s; now he can learn from the like’s of BES? Amazing.

  • SHINee52911

    ppl need 2 shut i agree

  • Kyl3er

    I think it’s a great opportunity for Taemin. I think his voice is very sweet sounding. I would love to see Onew on that show I think he would make it more fun and add personality to the songs but everyone knows Onew can sing.
    Immortal song is kinda boring for me after Jay left. It seems that everyone lacks creativity.
    Good luck Taemin!:)

  • Anonymous

    I’ve come to realise that lots of people, fans and non fans sure like to pigeon hole this kid. Not all of course but a lot. It seems to some that he can only be the ultimate prepubescent maknae of the kpop industry or the ultimate dancer and when he ventures out and actually does something different and unexpectd, it’s a bitch fest unlike we’ve ever seen!

    When I first heard that he was going to be participating in IS2, I was estatic. Over the moon even. I thought that this was a wonderful opportunity for him to learn and also to showcase how far he’s come.

    Then I read the comments and I was surprised. A lot of people were asking, ‘What about Onew?’ Onew is my bias in SHINee but not once did it cross my mind that he should be on the show instead of Taemin. We know Onew can sing, his voice is beautiful! But Taemin, who has made a significant improvement with his vocals, needs this more then Onew does. If nothing else, it’ll shut those people up who continue to believe that he can’t sing.

    I’m hoping through this he’lI be able to gain more confidence in his singing. He’s not as shy as he was the beginning of this year but it’ll definetly help in him become more confident. I also hope he learns to become more versatile and to become a better performer. Though I think SHINee as a whole has shown improvement in their performances ever since they went to Japan. I can’t wait to see it.

  • Mer

    In a musical landscape littered with a few talented singers and more than a few talentless, is it wrong to expect a competitive music show to showcase GREAT singers???  Taemin is an ok singer, but competitively he’s not that great.  I don’t get why that’s acceptable.   Shouldn’t he participate in a show that’s NOT a competition if SM wants him to have exposure??  It’s almost like dumbing down the class.  I think Minho is awesome (I’m that person), but I wouldn’t dare suggest he enters a singing competition.  You know being a “decent” singer is sometimes not enough.

    • Ilovemandoo

      I think that the difference is that Immortal Song’s focus seems to be on the performance-aspect.. their ability to adapt songs and connect with audiences. You can sing well, but it doesn’t necessarily mean that you’ll be able to do so. Because the show is focused on more than just singing, I think it’s perfectly acceptable (in this case) for PDs to be choosing singers who may not be considered the best. If the show were “I am a Singer,” it would be a completely different story.

  • kc

    man, I thought I was the only one who thought Taemin’s voice was pleasant…
    sometimes it feels like people don’t want Taemin to get better at singing, the kid’s gone a long way and seems to be working really hard to improve his voice yet people never seem to give him credit for it. What’s wrong with the main dancer improving his voice? if anything it’s a good thing for Shinee, I mean they already have Onew and Jonghyun, and even Key, why can’t Taemin work hard to get up to their level. to me it’s almost like they don’t want the team dynamic to change, that “oh, you do this, well keep doing it, don’t waist your time trying something else, just do that.” -.-
    as for Tae being on IS2… well I hesitated, thinking about all of the incredible talent on there, but you’ve convinced me that this would be the best place for someone like Taemin who still needs a bit of improvement on his voice. IS2 to me, while is a competition, is more exciting when you see an underdog step out of their comfort zone, when the person you hadn’t noticed before blows you away with their performance… and I mean, I think the sunbaes and coaches really do make the show as well, instead of fighting for the win they give each other support and cheer for each other- something you don’t really see in alot of reality competitions.
    I’m probably one of the few people who’d rather see Taemin’s improvement in singing then his excellent skills in dancing, to me it’s more exciting to see him grow in something he had a bit of difficulty in…. so I mean, while I don’t think he’s going to win, most likely he’ll be knocked down pretty early in the game, I have a feeling this’ll be a moment where he show’s people just what he’s got, cause I mean, even Shinee says that he works the hardest.

    good luck to him, I can’t wait to see what he does^^

  • http://twitter.com/allcrankedup nins

    i didnt know that shinee has still some korean activites cause i thought they would be busy promoting in japan. anyway,im just excited to watch taemin sing his heart out! GOODLUCK!! <3

  • Guest

    not the strongest vocals (and maybe not a choice contestant for the show idk), but very lovely and sweet. Taemin would probably hate me saying this, but his voice is pretty just like his face.

    I remember during the “Hello” video him stepping forward and opening his mouth. And I was like “where did this voice come from?” Up until then I had only really heard unimpressive recordings and horrendous lives from him. But now these videos show evidence that with some time and practice he could do consistently well.

    @ kc “[I'd] rather see Taemin’s improvement
    in singing then his excellent skills in dancing, to me it’s more
    exciting to see him grow in something he had a bit of difficulty in.” – amen

  • Mrs Junsu

    agree!! Taemin’s vocal might be not b the best… but I like the tone of his voice… it might not be as strong as JongHyun or Onew, but the softness in his voice make him sounds different…

    I believe TaeMin won’t disappoint us, or at least, me.
    ^^

  • Painless J

    “Heck, why stop at Taemin? Since Junsu has had his shot, why not put Junho or Wooyoung on the show! Taeyeon has gotten her (much well-deserved) dues already, so cast Seohyun, Tiffany, and maybe even Sunny! Yoseob is always fantastic, but let Hyunseung or Kikwang do their thing!  We already know KRY are awesome, give Sungmin and Donghae a chance in the vocal limelight!”

    Amen :)

  • Aya

    Hahahah, i also underestimate Jiyoon at first, i mean, the girl doesn’t have strong vocal so i was like “whaaatt..??!!” but then i took my words after i saw few of her performances. Might be not with the best vocal, but she put a great performances *damn you cube for putting HyunA too much air time*

    I think it’s a good choice to put him on some singing competition. We all know he improves a lot since his debut with his singing ability. Actually i think he tries to much to hit the high note it sounded annoying to the holly ears *note to hello* but when he doesn’t, his voice comes out good *and that’s not really a good thing because having comfort zone means that you wont improve* and putting him on immortal song will let him try other type of musics that might be suitable more to his voice than what SM has been put up to him. And it’s a good marketing *hail to sm for this one* if it comes to singing he will be out shined by the other members when he’s with shinee, so it’s his time, and being in immortal song will make a statement. But with all those concert and new album preparation……………..seriously SM, poor boy need to rest, have you seen his face lately? sometimes, he looks older than me.

    And the fact that his dancing ability starting to get a little bit dull and not getting anywhere, dont get me wrong, i think he’s the best male dancer in SM…that was until they put Kai’s, but that means he still in the top 3 at least for me. I dont know since when i thought he got stuck in it, his dancing ability, i mean. But right now when i see his dance performance, i always see the same thing again and again and again. He has a smooth moves which i dont really get why they put him in “specialize in popping” he can do it, i know, but it’s such a waste. Like when i saw him did salsa and tango i was like “oh you poor thing….sm….” such a waste waste waste. When he debuted, maybe popping was so cool…or i dont know? ..why sm? ….why?

  • juliaa

    YES
    honestly the main reason was probably because Onew had already done so many solo projects like MCing, variety shows, musicals and such. Taemin doesn’t get much exposure other than SHINee so I guess the producers wanted him because people don’t know Taemin as a single body yet. And it’s true the producers seem to want to pick people unexpected like woohyun over sungkyu, jiyeon over gayoon and minkyung over haeri. Not to mention Taemin’s voice is amazing he has a wide range and tons of potential.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=568847548 Rebekah Deng

    after reading this article, i so agree with u BRING OUT those other members!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DVKMGXH5V2QVTQNC2MUU4S2WVE Chocoholic

    Anybody knows when the season starts or started?? Please? THanks. :)

  • daniaaaye

    i actually love taemin’s whole package. i like shinee decently enough, but hello definitely sealed my admiration for maknae. his voice is soft, yes, like his image, and goddammit i’m a sucker that. makes me wanna melt into puddle of goo because who can resist pretty face with soft, soothing voice? the hyungs are all known to be good singers, packing powerful vocals, but i think taemin has shown the most improvement vocal-wise, and i wouldn’t be lying to admit that i’m listening to shinee nowadays just so i can swim in his barely there vocals. 

  • paeksul :3

    I agree with every point you made here. I mean, Taemin’s always being promoted as the “talented dancer” or the “cute maknae”; it’s time for him to show off some more and shed the labels people have put on him since his debut. He’s really gone a long way since his debut a few years ago and you can really tell that he’s improved a whole lot in terms of vocals and dancing.

    Taemin has a lot of potential and I’m glad they’re giving him a chance to hone that by casting him in Immortal Song. :D

    Taemin jjang!

  • paeksul :3

    I agree with every point you made here. I mean, Taemin’s always being promoted as the “talented dancer” or the “cute maknae”; it’s time for him to show off some more and shed the labels people have put on him since his debut. He’s really gone a long way since his debut a few years ago and you can really tell that he’s improved a whole lot in terms of vocals and dancing.

    Taemin has a lot of potential and I’m glad they’re giving him a chance to hone that by casting him in Immortal Song. :D

    Taemin jjang!

  • JesStal

    Love this article. I was extremely happy when I heard he was gna be participating on Immortal Song 2. The boy has seriously improved A LOT since their debut days. I attended the SHINee World concert over the summer and was impressed by his vocals. I knew he could pull off notes and sing but when he reached those high notes it was… wow. To the point where sometimes it was a little difficult to differentiate between him and Jonghyun. The only thing I’m slightly worried is his stage presence. Being quite the shy one and usually having his ‘hyungs’ do the talking I’m a bit worried on how he will interact with the audience. Nonetheless looking forward to his first show! :) and of course SHINee’s comeback! 

  • Dragonhearteiji

    i just love this.

  • CRAZYCRYSTAL93

    you know what, i dont post comments on anything and i was only on this website because i watch immortal song and thought “oh i wonder if taemin is going on it or if people were mistaken” and im honestly shocked at everycomment and article i have read about this beucase taemin is an amazing singer and no he is not my bias im not even a fan of shinnee i like about one song and i dont have favorites in idol groups i care abotu the music. i think its rediculous that people like a band because the singers a hot or they are good at dancing its music for cryign out loud its about the music you should be listening to the music otherwise the group you saw you like are entertainers not musicians and taemin has a powerful voice hes just as good as jonghyun or onew or key or even minho who by the way is quite a good singer as well. taemin will not disappoint and its quite insulting that people believe he will, if you happen to see makbanshi the episode with shinnee showed how hard he tries at singing and how much he wants to be good at it and he really is.
    im not sure if i haev a distorted view of the world but his voice has power, emotion and a control that one only gets through experience. kyung min frojm immortal song is also someone i believe is probably one of the best korean singers i have ever heard and i listen to a lot of music from not only korean and asia but from many other countries as well i fail to see how people dont have faith in him to be a good singer just like people dont with infinite’s woohyun and taemin.  

  • vivi

    Yeah Taemin should be knowing as a singer too

    He has that talentedbut I really like onew and minho voice
    so calm…… relaxing,refreshing
    they shoul train Minho also
    But The point for me is 

    Why Don’t SM just give them a breaktime
    Onew get sick now
    He is so tired….
    I just want they happy with all that busy schedule
    even in new year
    just remember how onew pass last Chinee’s new year with working

  • Tokobyyoko

    I truly agree with your opinion. Jonghyun’s voice is powerful and beautiful , Onew is skilled and his voice melts my heart, Key has unique voice and I love his solos, Minho tries hard to increase his vocal skills, but when it comes to my favorite SHINee’s  songs like Romeo+Juliet, Romance, One , Taemin’s  parts are something very important to me. I’m gonna wait to see babyTaemin in IS and submit that he is grown-up young man, not longer little Taeminnie :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Taemin-Lee/100002564632375 Taemin Lee

    AGREEEEEE, HE CAN SING VERY WELL !!!!!!!!!!!

  • Quickeynickey_25

    I agree with your arguments. People who say that taemin can’t sing are mean. They’re not even giving him a chance. Indeed he’s not the one with the best vocal in the group, but his voice is as beautiful as any other singers I know. If they say that immortal song is supposed to be reserved for people with the vocals like jonghyun and onew, then it shouldnt be any fun at all, because they’re already good at it. Taemin can sing. He has the potential to be better, not that he’s not good right now. I agree with every word that you say. Seriously, people should stop being mean and just let him get the limelight once in a while. He deserves it after years of training anyway. They think he spent 7 years just polishing his dance skills? He sings too!

    Taemin daebak!! Don’t care about those meanies, taemin uppa still can do it!

  • Silverxrain

    this article is perfect

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001584969546 Karolina Śniady

    I think that its good that Taemin is on Immortal Song now. We should comfort him! Whats the matter, people? His voice is beautiful, i cry every time i listen to him and he deserves for positive opinions, because he works so hard! Dont hate, just love him as he is! 

  • http://www.facebook.com/Eizy.Espinoza Eizy Espinoza

    I totally agree with you, and not just because he is my bis or anything, but because even though he is not the best singer he has a beautiful voice and sings very well, I cried when I heard him singing ”I’ll do well” from Se7en. Just because no one ever gave him a chance to really show his talent doesn’t mean he can’t sing. They should at least give him a chance to show his real potential before judging him.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001108867077 Red Heart Cassiopeia

    I really believe that our maknae taeminnie oppa can do it….
    I mean, come on!! he’s an amazing singer who has a sweet voice!
    just listen to SHINee’s romantic! although he’s young, his voice is above average of a singer!
    he can even sing Jonghyun’s parts when Jonghyun’s not around.
    I have no doubt that he’s fit to be in immortal song show!

  • lil.c_14

    *stands up and claps*

    This was really beautiful and perfect. I think everyone should read this.You said everything that was needed to be said perfectly.

  • Mallorycarty

    I completely agree, and no, not just because he’s my ultimate bias.

    I’ve always had faith in Taemin when it comes to singing. He’s definitely shown that he’s improved, what with all the big parts he was given in THE FIRST (Japanese album). He did fabulous! Yet… People still doubt his singing ability…

    Taemin has a very unique singing voice, in my opinion. I love hearing it – it makes my heart flutter. Why? I think because it sounds so soft and sweet. I can hear emotion when he sings. Not that I can’t hear it with Onew or Jjong, but… I don’t know. i can’t explain it. Taemin’s is just… different.

    I’m so proud of him. I truly am. It’s obvious that he loves to sing, and he’s working hard at it. So when I heard that he was going to be on this show, I was very excited for him. I still am. I feel it’ll be a big help to him, and he’ll look back on the experience with a smile. I’m sure his hyungs are supporting him like crazy, and that they’re proud of him too. I doubt Onew or Jjong are jealous – they’re probably ecstatic because their dongsaeng is finally getting this chance to shine! This chance to shine, not physically, but vocally.

    Which is something that I feel Taemin truly deserves.

    So, to the people who are complaining in some way, shape, or form? I’m extremely disappointed in you. What kind of true Shawol would be so disapproving and non-supportive? Reorganize your thoughts a bit, and find it in your heart to support Taemin, instead of bashing him. That’s what a true Shawol would do.

    To those who are worried about him? Don’t be. Taemin’s a big boy – he can take care of himself. I’m sure he knows that he’s not a perfect singer, and I’m sure he knows he’s not a powerhouse vocalist. That doesn’t matter. Taemin is going to get through this with a smile. I guarantee you. He’s going to learn some things, and he’s going to have fun with it. Because he’s Taemin. He’s a fabulous person who just wants to improve and do the best he can. So please, don’t worry about him. The best thing you can do is show your support.

    To those who are supporting him with all your heart? Keep doing what you’re doing. You guys are awesome.

    To REE – Thank you so much for writing this. I’m sure it changed a lot of people’s minds. Personally, i loved it. So thank you. :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1411180191 Blair Jamie Hentz

    This is great, my friend[just below me actually.^^] sent me this link.
    I think it’s great that Taemin is finally getting a chance to shine..
    Minho is my bais[and that "People go as far as to put him on the same par as Minho" part hurt...he's a beautiful singer.T^T], but I love them all so much, it’s impossible for me to rank them!
    I’m proud of Taemin and I hope he takes a lot of knowledge and wonderful memories from this!

    I’m sure he’s not that full of himself that he thinks he’s the best. But I defffinitely hope people will turn around and believe in him and become a true Shawol and love him and his voice as much as the next member.

    Taemin Hwaiting!!^o^

    o 3o

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1411180191 Blair Jamie Hentz

    This is great, my friend[just below me actually.^^] sent me this link.
    I think it’s great that Taemin is finally getting a chance to shine..
    Minho is my bais[and that "People go as far as to put him on the same par as Minho" part hurt...he's a beautiful singer.T^T], but I love them all so much, it’s impossible for me to rank them!
    I’m proud of Taemin and I hope he takes a lot of knowledge and wonderful memories from this!

    I’m sure he’s not that full of himself that he thinks he’s the best. But I defffinitely hope people will turn around and believe in him and become a true Shawol and love him and his voice as much as the next member.

    Taemin Hwaiting!!^o^

    o 3o

  • bubblybubbles

    Good luck Taemin !!! It’s your turn to shine!!!

  • Mia Majapuro

    Wau, I really, really liked this article/writing. Because you see a lot of stuff written about famous people that just seems so… mushy? Some people simply defend their bias by saying that people should understand because that person is just so awesome and a kind, good, hard-working person, and what not, but then it just doesn’t convince because it lacks reasoning… But this text right here, my gosh, love the actual digging into the different points of view.

    And so it’s easy to understand and agree with this text. So I want to express a big thank you for that.

    And then onward to other comments:
    In my opinion too, especially when listening to SHINee’s first album with all the Replays and those songs, and then Lucifer, I could really really notice the improvement in everyone, and especially Taemin. And I gotta say, when first listening to SHINee, I was not struck by Taemin’s voice immediately, but after listening to the group and then songs for a while, I kind of grew to realize the different parts, the different voices of each singer more and more, their colors and feeling, and all the nuances that come along with those. And I really grew to like Taemin’s voice, a lot so. Although it was not immediate, but his little parts (and as established, later on bigger ones) started to “kick in”. I remember especially the part right before the chorus in Romantic where Taemin “waou”s the ending really impressed me. But it was not so much because of his wickedness in singing, no. It is clear that he’s not a fully grinded diamond in terms of vocal skills, however, his voice has character, and that’s one thing I love most about singers’ voices — if it has character, it’s unique and it is memorable and recognizable. I really, really grew to like the flavor of his voice, and the more I concentrated on his parts, the more I could feel the soul out of them.
       And this is not to say that I did not feel that from the other members. But since now we’re talking especially about Taemin…
       Also, I am very much looking forward to the years ahead to see the development in Taemin, because for sure I think he’s one of those unique voices I love to listen to. And it’s also actually very refreshing and inspirational to see a person who is not so much a miracle can-do-it-all-perfectly guy who one day just popped out of somewhere and frlom then on kept blowing our minds with his superhuman skill in everything, but rather is actually a human whose talent is still in its raw form, like stated before, that we get to see in the process of development. I think that’s a lot more interesting and touching, because there’s a story to see and to listen to.

    But, all in all, talking about SHINee as a whole, I think this group is quite special, because it’s not only Taemin who has a unique flavor, but it’s all of them, and their sound together is awesome in my opinion. ‘Cause honestly, be it a singer or a group, but there are too many out there that sound too much the same. But these guys, oh no, it’s like instantly you hear any of them sing, you recognize that that’s SHINee right there. Though again not saying here that there aren’t other k-groups with unique sounds like SHINee, but I’m pretty sure you already figured that out. But you never can be too careful… XD

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/P3HW7YG5IQEXUJJIENPOK74QOM Coco

    I admit, on the debut, Taemin was one of the worst singers I’ve heard. But he improved a lot and I was amazed by it!

    I don’t like your blog either (no offense) but this article is awesome! You finally put some clear logical thoughts where other fans couldn’t.

    Btw. sorry, english is my fourth language^^”

    Anyway Immortal Song 2 is one of my favorite korean shows and I was very disappointed when great singers like Yesung, Jonghyun, Yoseop had to leave so early due to their schedules. I would have loved to hear more songs because Immortal Song 2 is really showing their TRUE potential. Except for Yesung and Hyorin and IU. They have always been amazing. But Yoseop and Jonghyun for example, I think they improved and showed everyone they can sing wonderful.

    Taemin already has a lot of spotlight, especially from fans. Even more than ANY of the other SHINee members I noticed. Jonghyun is the one who is not getting enough recognition. This is all based on my observation in the internet, comments, polls and by watching shows.

    Onew has had musical offers, so his singing abilities are recognised, so, like you wrote, Taemin has to be pushed as a singer.

    Still: To be honest I still feel bad for Jonghyun for being that unpopular compared to the other SHINee members. I like everyone equally in the band but I couldn’t help but notice.

    Great article! Keep going:-)

  • Anonymous

    Immortal Song 2 was pretty awesome. I watched it all in two days, marathon-style, I couldn’t stop. The hosts were great, the concept was great – I LOVED learning about Korean musical legends -, the singers were great. Of course, I had my dislikes (like how flashy performances would win against more heartfelt songs, and at some points I started doubting that there were only legends’ fans voting and not idol-biased fans). But it was an amazing opportunity to enjoy music, in all its aspects – from the making/re-arranging of the songs, to old singers sharing the scene with the younger generation, beautiful performances, creative acts, and so on. It’s definitely one of my favorite K shows.
    I’m surprised people went as far as to consider this show a joke just because Taemin takes part in it now. Sure I was somewhat surprised, but only because I was used to the best of the best (Hyorin, Yesung), and still, though I do not follow Shinee, I somehow was under the impression Taemin was decent (though I’d based my judgment on only one performance). Actually, the fact that he got chosen only makes me more curious.
    I like what you said in the end, about giving other people the chance to shine, because IS2 isn’t really just a show off of who can reach the hardest notes, but it’s also about putting passion and creativity in what you do, and offering something to those who listen to you; so anyone can have that chance to prove (and improve) themselves.
    “We already know KRY are awesome, give Sungmin and Donghae a chance in the vocal limelight!”
    I simply love this. As a SJ fan, I’m tired of the “let KRY have an album/concert” thing. They sing like half of the songs already, and are acknowledged as the best singers in the group. OT, but I’d want Leeteuk or Henry (or even Ryeouk) to make an album of their compositions, make duets/trios with Shindong, Eunhyuk or Zhoumi or idk what else. The possibilities are many.
    Back to the point, as for Sungmin and Donghae, I admit when I watched IS2 I was quite sad thinking Sungmin wouldn’t be able to climb on that stage ever. But then I listened to Muldeuro and thought maybe he’s not that bad. I’d love it if him and Kangin took the IS2 stage, for example. Donghae would be nice too, but mostly for the re-arranging and composition. I’m afraid he might not have the best vocal range. Hmm.

  • Anonymous

    I agree with everything you have written. I must say, I never expected to be so impressed. We all know Jjong and Onew can sing, but when Taemin was announced I must admit I was surprised.  I have watched every episode and he improves steadily each time.  What really is impressive, in my opinion, in the composure and grace with which he is handling this whole thing. He has stepped out of his comfort zone, he is surrounded by experienced singers and legends in his industry, and everyone, including myself, is captivated! Also consider he was working on SHINee’s comeback, Minho’s TV drama, and voice work for Koala Kid during this time. His voice is lovely, his dancing, of course, superb….and his personality is so sweet.  Everyone can see how hard he is working and I think he deserves nothing but praise.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1153237472 Melanie Faith Guido Brunet

    Taemin did so well on the show, IMHO. I think he’s a good singer. Sure his dancing is phenom, but he’s also got a lovely soft voice. 

    I don’t get why people are so hard on Minho. He’s a good singer/rapper too! What’s wrong with peoples’ ears? 

  • Fooz57

    Taemin’s final stage was unbelieveable!  He had everyone in the palm of his hand!! So happy for him.  This was a joy to watch.