Music / Idols
20111202_seoulbeats_shinee2

Roundtable: If I were an idol…

51
Written by On December 2, 2011

Amy and Subi discussed what ideal groups they would most want to be a part of and they both agreed on SHINee during last week’s podcast.  We decided to ask our team the same question — what idol group do you guys want to be a part of and what role would you like to fulfill? 


Subi: I picked SHINee simply because they are BOSS at everything. They can sing, they can dance, they can do everything an idol should do and do it well. On top of that, they have some really fun songs with fun dances that I would LOVE to perform. And as to what role I would like to fulfill, while I might have said Key, the catch all member, I’m going to retract my statement.

I am a MUCH better rapper than Minho. Yeah, there I said it. I’ve got more flow than him and I would do that group as a whole so much more justice than Minho ever could. Am I as pretty as Minho? The jury is still out on this one but this group needs a legit rapper.  I could be that legit rapper.

Ree: Dude, EVERYONE is a better rapper than Minho. I actually wouldn’t mind joining SHINee either, since they’re so well rounded. But if I had to choose an idol group, I’d say After School. Because I am young, I still have a few years left till they sideline me. Also, their comebacks are always so badass. They put their all into it, they really do. And to be under the wing of Kahi is just an honour in itself, forreal.

Although I wish I could be Kahi, NO ONE can be Kahi. So instead I will take the place Bekah had, as the underappreciated rapper with the attitude. I wouldn’t mind being Lizzy either, since she’s so cute. You know, I’d choose to be a mesh of Bekah, Lizzy, and Nana. Also, since AS isn’t the most talented group around, if I fail to fulfill my role, I would not get as much flack. Haha.

Runner up for girl group I’d be in is Miss A. Because I LOVE their concept. It’s so ungimmicky, and it’s everything I’d want in a girlgroup. I love the productions of their songs, and as a group they’re also very well rounded. And, I’d want to be Jia. Because. She. Is. BOSS. She’s an amazing dancer, a good singer (her voice is my favourite after Fei’s), and her I actually like her rapping. If not Jia, then I’d want to be Fei :3

If I had to choose a male idol group I’d say DBSK, but I’d just mess up the already perfect dynamic, so instead it’s a toss up between 2AM/2PM and Super Junior.

I’d actually much rather be a part of 2AM over 2PM or SuJu. Since they are RIDICULOUS, SASSY AND AMAZING. But the issue is they’re a ballad group. And I want to move around performing, and although 2AM are pretty ridiculous when they do special stages, their promotional material is all ballads. I can’t handle that. Otherwise they’d be perfect.

Megan: As far as sheer fail in rapping goes, I think SNSD could give Minho a run for his money. SHINee does actually sound like a great group to be a part of. I don’t envy the stylists that SM gives them, but they sure get kickass choreography and nice ballads. I’d be the Key: competent at everything, bitchy, with wacky hair and a questionable sense of style. I’d also do a great job at landing the group in hot water all the time over questionable comments.

As far as girl groups go: Miss A, yes please. Jia is just the coolest gal, ever, and I’m her undying fangirl for life. Plus, the Miss A girls are so unfussy, they haven’t done any overly ridiculous concepts or been squeezed into lolita costumes. I’d like to be the Jia as well, the awesome chick. CL babe, I love you, but Jia is just more effortlessly badass.

Actually, I wouldn’t mind being a member of SNSD either. Lord knows they need a member that can bring the bitch attitude properly. Jessica has her “ice queen” thing, but girl ain’t putting her heart in it. She’s naturally a fluffy, pink sort of girl. They all are, as a matter of fact, except for perhaps Hyoyeon. I could be BFFs with Hyoyeon and be the “little girl with a big voice” in the group.

Nabeela: I would want to be CL from 2NE1. I love her attitude plus she’s got this unconventional bordering on controversial sense of style that i am just so jealous of. Performance wise, CL is a great vocalist as well a great rapper, and she has a commanding stage presence–you just have to look at her
Also if you watch her on 2NE1 TV and other YG related shows, she’s very down to earth and isnt afraid to front the cameras bare faced and in baggy clothing. She’s very confident in who she is and her talents, and i would kill to be her. I would also love to be Bom too, just because she’s so freakin hot, and I love her plastic fantastic face. There, i admit it.

Also also also, I wouldn’t mind being in f(x) just because their image really matches my own fashion sense. I think I would be Sulli, even though I have this love-hate relationship with her. But she’s very spunky on stage and I like that.

Madina: I’d vote for Sandara Park – that hair thingie’s gotta be worth something!

Johnelle: If I had any kind of singing or dancing talent at all I’d wanna be in the Brown Eyed Girls because they’re just bad ass, they know it, they do the music they want how they want, and don’t really care about what anyone else thinks.

Now if we’re talking boy bands and a covert girl posing as a boy operation, I’d want to have been in DBSK pre-break up because I think there would have been a lot of interesting secrets to have been found out there like: did YunJae really exist, how much porn did Changmin watch, how many girls did Yoochun go out with, and how did Junsu get that butt?

Fannie: For me, it’s a toss-up in between Miss A and 2NE1. Miss A because I like their style of being powerful, classy girls with some swag, and 2NE1 because I like their style of being powerful, swag-carrying girls with some class. See the pattern of my preference?

I love all the members in Miss A, but if I were to choose one to be, I would be Fei. Because she’s so freaking gorgeous (on top of being talented), and plus I’d get to be best friends with my badass girl-crush, Jia. I also feel that JYP is the company with the friendliest and most down-to-earth idols, and I may be in the minority on this one, but I even have a strange fondness for JYP himself and his troll-like ways. I take the fact that he’s more involved and interactive with his idols than other CEOs/heads to be a good thing. I also thought that the JYP Nation This Christmas MV put out last year takes the cake for being the most heartwarming thing ever.

As for 2NE1, even though I feel like their sound has been starting to stagnate lately, I love how these girls know how to perform on stage. And I mean, not just mouth some lines and do the choreography, but actually PERFORM and have fun and feed off the audience. I also would LOVE the perks of being in YG. Some really amazing stuff goes on in that company. And I like how every personality in YG is so unique and yet kind of awkward in their own endearing way. If I were to pick one member of 2NE1 to be I would be CL. I really admire not only her stage presence, but also her confidence in herself. Nothing can faze this girl or make her question her self-worth, and I think that’s a really important quality to have when you’re part of the entertainment industry.

Also — never would I want to be in group of more than 5 members.

How about you — which idol group would you want to be part of and why?

Related Posts

TAGS: , , , , , ,
  • Anonymous

    2NE1, hands down. I would want to be in 2NE1. If it wasn’t obvious already, I’m a huge stan. I love every thing about them. If was to magically become one of the members one day it would either be CL or Minzy. Like most other people said during the roundtable, CL is just fierce as hell, not only on stage but in real life. She’s totally amped on stage and she commands your attention, but off-stage she’s chill, humble, but still has a force about her. I love that. I love how confident she is in herself and how she doesn’t let anything phase her. Girl’s got swag dripping off her. I love it.

    If I couldn’t be CL, I’d definitely be Minzy. She’s the most talented in the group, in my opinion. She’s got natural rythm and she’s an amazing dancer, she’s got those soulful vocals you’d want to listen to for hours on end, and she can rap circles around you if she really wanted to. Plus, she’s super chill in real life, almost never does aegyo, and instead opts to plant, read, paint, or spend all day in dance practice. She’s awesome. I love the maknaes. And the other upside of being either of them would be being bestfriends with Dara and Bom. The Park Sisters are hilarious. I wouldn’t want to be either of them, but I’d definitely want to be friends with them.

    If I were in a boy group, it would definitely be Big Bang. I’d be Taeyang, but that would be a little problematic because … I couldn’t date myself. That’s a problem. But I guess I could if I really wanted to. Hell, I’m Taeyang. I can do whatever I want! Hahah, jokes aside, Taeyang has this very naive and awkward appeal to him when he’s offstage. He seems so innocent, but so masculine at the same time. And when he’s on stage, he completely transforms and puts his all into his performances. He has swag; it’s just a different kind than GD and TOP. And another perk of being Taeyang would be that I’d be bestfriends with GD . Swoon.

    Honestly, I’d be anyone in YG. I love all of them. I love how strong Goo Hye Sun and Gummy are. I love how unique each one of them is. I love how quirky all their personalities are and I love how much stage presence they have. I love how much charisma they all have.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LL4QDJLVFDT2RDIZYBALSE75JE angel29

      That was funny… You not being able to date yourself. And I don’t think Taeyang swoons around GD. Haha. I hope not.

      As for me, I want to be in 2NE1.  They are hardworking, funny, and humble offstage and they are solid on stage.  And instead of coming up with a long explanation why and who I want to be, I thought of copying and pasting everything you said about them but it would be too obvious… so I’ll just say ME TOO!

      • Anonymous

        Hahah! If I was Taeyang, I would definitely swoon around GD. Give them GDYB shippers something to talk about ;D Hahah

    • http://thoughtfulpaper.wordpress.com milaiski

      I so agree with you. I could be anyone in YG. Even a manager. XD I just love the company dynamics as a whole. :)

  • tegami

    I’d love to be a part of Block B, if only to be able to witness Zico’s nudist stints around their dorm before he takes a shower XD

  • asdfg

    Everyone wants to be in 2NE1 or miss A because they are awesome. No girly girl crap from them, just badassness. I would be Fei because she is ridiculously well-rounded. Awesome at singing and dancing, except for variety, but she doesn’t need that to show how talented she is. When I watched her in Chinese variety shows, she’s actually hilarious, so she’s just uncomfortable being funny on Korean shows

  • minnie

    Any group in JYP just because they’re are all so close to JYP, therefore I can troll around and mess with him. The entire family is just very down to earth and funny and I admire that.

  • http://twitter.com/Zain9898 Zain

    I would love to be in miss a or 2ne1. I love all the girls in these two groups. Jia so pretty and i love her hairstyles and i really like suzy so i would love to be friends with them. Min also can speak a little english so it would be easy to communicate with them. Miss a has a great style of being sexy with class and sass. JYP is someone i would love to hang out with if what i saw in dream high is true. He seems to be a great character and very fun. 2ne1 is awesome. On stage all the girls are badass and poweful like cl and minzy but off stage they are so adorkable. Watching 2ne1 season 2 showed how awesome they are. Plus i can hang out with big bang and the other yg members. Seriously from what Tablo said about them it seems like great things are happening in yg and watching their concert preparations they all seemed to get along so well. I am also kinda awkward and don’t like to be on tv so much so its perfect. Really my two favorite companies are jyp and yg and they both seem to be close to each other. 

  • guest

    I would choose big bang (even though i’m a girl). Big Bang and YG have done a good job of letting each individual member showcase their individual talents through solo acts. Also I think after a while i wouldn’t be satisfied with just performing songs made by a company’s songwriters. I would hope to be involved in the actual songwriting and producing which GD is famous for. YG also has a great rep for protecting their talents. And I think out the members i could take seungri’s place – i would so share big bangs secrets  

  • LA

    2ne1 because their company treated them well. There is no a “15 variety shows a day but at the end we only receive 5 shows worth amount of money” work. There is no a “lame and we get no words but just sing a part that our company has decided” song.

  • Anonymous

    I’d love to be in any YG group.

    They’re just so chill and cool and awkward and funny ridiculous.  God I love them. Imagine the stuff that goes on behind the scenes. Like I would die to actually party and drink with the YG boys. Not to mention, their amazing building. So many toys and fabulous facilities. They get overworked too but they get really long breaks, the length of which is almost unheard of in the idol world.

    I’d like to be Bom if I’m in 2NE1. Play around and be dorky and just come out when it’s my turn and blow off the stage with my pipes.

  • Anonymous

    GD 
    I’ll just leave it as that. 

  • http://twitter.com/TigerHolland Tiger Holland

    Sometimes I think I’d like to be in 4Minute, just to see if everyone resents Hyuna and all the promotion and press she gets. It would also be incredibly awesome to be in 2NE1 (Minzy’s role, maybe?) or the Wondergirls (Sunye’s role). I couldn’t pull off Miss A’s choreography, but I’d love to hang out with Jia. I heard so much buzz about Suzy on the internet, I thought I was the only one who liked Jia best–it’s nice to know that she’s a favorite here, too. :-)

  • Anonymous

    I’d like to be in Miss A. I love BEG and 2ne1 as well, but I feel as if I belong in Miss A more. Maybe it’s because I haven’t breached my twenties yet. All three groups are badass. But I’m not very bad as. I’d probably be better as a sugary-sweet idol like IU… but I want to be in Miss A.

    I’d like to be SNSD JUST to wear their “The Boys” stage clothing. That’s the only reason. They’re back to uniforms now for “Mr. Taxi,” though :( .

    If I were a boy, I’d want to be Key (SHINee), because he’s a diva and pretty well-rounded in what he does. Or I’d want to be Myungsoo/L (INFINITE) because he has an awesome smolder. Being in Big Bang would also be great, too.

  • happyslip

    lol, I’d want to be in 2ne1 too. I’d like (at least) to experience the fun they get to have with their songs, concepts and performances. I’d like to hang-out with those girls the most. Imagine the funny and quirky moments with Bom, picture frenzy days with Dara lol, interesting conversations with Minzy (btw, have you seen some of the things she posts on twitter?)…and just ultimately practice and be with a performer like CL.

    A big bonus? Dayum their chill colleagues in YGE (Kush gets a special mention lol). I wouldn’t really mind staying there, nope.

    • thunderandsmoke

      I completely forgot about Kush! I bet hanging out with him is epic…

      • Anonymous

        KUSH!! Hahah, I love him.

  • Aya

    Definitely BEG for…an obvious reason…i would love love love to be Miryo or Jea. Ooh..Secret’s Zinger and AS’s Bekah…..and yes, i have a thing for females rapper with a hip and thigh to be proud of.

  • Skye

    I’d probably like to be a part of Super Junior. There would be so much fun going on in there, they get to do some thrilling live stages (shitty MVs will stay shitty) and it’s not like anyone could fairly call out on me if I failed at something, lol. Plus, they get a lot of variety shows/radio dj-ing, which I’d love to try to do. And so many people. Idk, I’ve always thought that given the chance, I’d love to be a part of that.

    If I do have to choose a girl group, though, it’d be either Miss A (I love those girls) or 2NE1. I like the attitude and I’d go along with that much better than I’d go along with the excessive cutesy of most of the groups out there. I love their onstage fashion and their music seems just so fun to perform, I’d love to be a part of that.

    As for the role, in any group I’d like to be a rapper, to be honest. I’d really like to know how to rap (maybe I do have some talent! who knows, since I’ve never, ever tried), so I’d kill for that position. Also, I’d be the bitchy member of the group (one of them, in the SJ case). In 2NE1 I’d also be a bit of a tomboy and Bom and I would spent our lives stealing food. THERE. I SAID IT. I’d be the one STEALING THE FOOOOD and forgetting about dieting. That would be my main role, tbh x____D

  • frou-frou

    I’d join Teen Top…and murder them in their beds.

  • Bervalvic

    I would definitely love to be apart of a YG group, their talent is pretty well rounded and I love their sound of music

    If there was an exact version of a female shinee i would be in it

    I would do and After School sub group, I dont have to be talented just pretty and thin

    I’d love to be in BEG but I’m not talented enough, but I’d like to be apart of that company because it seems like they have creative control and they are unique

  • Anonymous

    this is probably the most interesting topic in seoulbeats XDDD i would love to be Bom in 2NE1 since ‘i (oh, i mean Bom)’ have the undeniably one of the most beautiful voices in kpop hehe. + i love how YG makes her wearing those micro mini dresses cause she does have long fit but not-skinny legs. and not to mention the honor of being a part of YGE, the Family is very cool and i until now am still dreaming to be one of them.
    if i were a guy id love to be a part of 2AM. love the music and the warmth in JYP clan.
    in addition, i want to star WGM with lee seung gi lol

  • Brent

    So many things to say about this…
    1. “CL babe, I love you, but Jia is just more effortlessly badass.” the best sentence from this article ever! Jia is everything and more when it comes to an idol. The voice, performance ability, dancing skill, rapping, and straight up attitude without trying to hard. I do love CL and think she is great on the stage, but I think she can force it and go overboard sometimes and it feels weird, and overall I can’t seriously stand 2NE1 that well anymore and think Miss A is a much better group.
    2. I love the love Fei is getting from you guys. She is so dang beautiful she blows me away every time and she has a great voice (I was really disappointed in the amount and kind of parts she was given in Goodbye Baby)
    3. If I was in a group I would be in 2pm because I love their energy and performance ability. I also really dig their style being a little more “Western”. Also I would really like those guys help on how to get a nice six pack. The part I would fit would be that 2nd best singer in the group  (wouldn’t be that hard in 2pm) that gets to sing most verses and rapper because well Nickhun needs some back up help.
    4. In an alternate universe if I was to be in a girl group it would either be Rainbow or Nine Muses. I would have to cut out some other useless girls first, but I love both of their seriously sexy yet classy look and feel. I picked them because with each new single they are continuously improving and they are at an early enough stage in their career that they still have time and talent enough to become A class idol groups. I kind of have a feeling that Nine Muses management will ruin them, but I sincerely hope that DSP continues to do Rainbow well, they have an awesome balanced group their I love to watch. For what I would be in the group, I would probably just want to be the “face” and possibly “the dancer” that way I wouldn’t have to do anything but be sexy and do CFs and then get into “acting”.

  • thunderandsmoke

    YG and JYP seem like the best kpop companies to work for. I feel like most of the time, their artist are having a good time, and their lives don’t seem to scripted. You get the feeling like they get to at least act like themselves and be who they are, yet still work hard and do what they’re supposed to do. Male group wise for who I’d like to be a part of , Big Bang takes first place. You get fancy, super cool outfits, you sing awesome songs. You get to hang out with Taeyang, GD, Daesung, and the wonderful ladies of 2NE1 (I would make it my life goal to be Bom’s best friend). Perhaps I’d be Taeyang, because he just seems like the guy that everyone likes. Super chill, nice, kind of shy (girls dig that), attractive as hell, and talented, with a quirky sense of humor. And you get to hang out/party with GD and Se7en. Nice. Second place goes to MBLAQ: I feel like outside of performing, the get to do whatever the hell they want. And they are all hilarious, so you know you’re going to have a good time all the time. Plus on stage, while performing they feed off each other so well. Same with Big Bang. Girl group wise, I would love to be in 2NE1. Onstage=awesome, sexy, swagged out. Offstage=weird, sexy, hilarious, still awesome. All the members of 2NE1 seem like great people to work with and be around on a daily basis. They’re all interesting offstage and seem so down to earth and fun. Would definitely go out to eat with Bom and perhaps shopping with CL. One last point: I think I’d like to be Jonghyun of SHINee as well mainly because of just how cool I think he is.

  • Anonymous

    I would love to be CL, that girl can sing and rap and you can see that she genuinely loves the stage. I also think JiA is effortlessly badass but I personally would love to work for YGE. What I like about both girls is that they bring it on stage and in real life you can see that both girl’s have a strong sense of who they are and that probably is why they are so baddass on stage.  

    I like JYP and I think both companies are probably the best in regards to treatment of their artists but I personally like YGE’s music more and the fact that he lets their artists have vacations and doesn’t force them to be on variety shows gets major points from me.  Don’t get me wrong YGE follows the trends just like any other company but unlike the other two YGE comes off as a company that is more focused on putting out genuinely good performers (yes I know DARA is a big blaring exception to the talent pool) rather than idol personalities/entertainers.  He doesn’t force his artists to show up on every variety show known to man and doesn’t make them work non-stop all of the time to become entertainers and what results is a bunch of a singers whose focus is mostly on the music where it should be.  Also YGE allows his artists to enjoy the stage which I don’t see in companies from JYP and SME.  Even though JiA is badass she still is limited on her freedom in her performances and has to for the most part stick with the lyrics and choreography and for that reason I wouldn’t want to be her. 

    Plus I would love to hang out with TOP,Teddy,and Kush in the studio much more than 2pm. Sorry 2pm fans. 

  • http://twitter.com/AuNaturale_Yau MzChungai

    For girl groups, I would love to be in 2NE1, BEG or Miss A. These groups have the passion for music and they genuinely love their songs and performing them. While for the boys, it has to be BigBang. In my opinion, the boys are in it for  purely the music and are only appreciative of the other perks that came along with it (actually, this can be said for all YG artistes). Honestly, I would just love to be in YGE. They love music/art and know how to appreciate it; it doesn’t matter from what genre. Sure, they come of unfriendly because they’re not the ‘go-luck happy’ types.But they’re very respectful of others and very tight with their actual friends. This attitude is more real to me than those who are excessively friendly. YGE  is also filled with goofiness, they just know how to tame it when in public…lol.
    Rather than wanting to be this person, I  just really admire her (and a bit jealous too). The person is CL. A lot has been said about her in other comments, so I will just summarize my reasons. 
    1. Leadership skills- the fact that she has been able to effectively lead a group with very diverse characters from the age of just 17, props to her. She manages to instruct two women 7yrs older than her without coming off rude (it helps that her unnies are very laid back too).
    2. She is both book and life smart. Just listen or read  her  interviews or watch her on 2ne1tv.
    3. Her self-confidence without being proud is very appealing. She is also assertive without being rude (even to YG himself).
    4.Her emotions are genuine and  she is humble. (I love that she smiles and laughs a lot).
    5.She is multifaceted and a born-performer.
     I’ll just stop here, so as not to come off as a cray-cray fan (I think I am …lol). To me, she is the ultimate ” Mother’s friend daughter” ( not sure if that is the right expression) and she is still so young so there’s still more to be unfold. She totally won me over when I saw she sleeps with music in her ears and loves to travel (just like me).

    Another person who comes close to CL is Minzy. Everyday there is something that surprises me about her and she still as a long way to her prime days.  I also really like Fei, Min and Sunye. 

  • Anonymous

    haha love this article and the comments! :3

    though super junior seems fun, i still want to join 2pm. i love these guys, their closeness doesn’t seems fake, not so much “gap” between members, and they always know how to play around in varieties. if i have to choose, i’d definitely pick wooyoung. i am (wooyoung is :p) the most all-rounded performer and the best boyband member: can sing, can dance, can joke around, seems to be close with all members, and carry on this “happy virus” title. he is kinda like eunhyuk in suju, but he definitely can sing. 

    and though i’d face difficulties, being in a group like jyj is simply amazing. i love their closeness, their junsu’s bullying, their unplanned but funny antics in interviews, and everything about them. i can’t choose between those three though. xD

    as for girl groups, i really love the dynamic in t-ara. seeing them on stage and off stage, i’m convinced at their close relationship. snsd also share this closeness, but sometimes some of them are just sticking to their closest friend and ditch the rest. 

    and if i were t-ara, i’d definitely be eunjung and marry jangwoo after i finish my career in girl group. period.

    • Anonymous

      oh i forgot to mention this, who wouldn’t want to be iu? she’s a cute girl everyone love ^^ if i were iu, i’d have yoseob, wooyoung, and kikwang on palm of my hand, how’s that sound? :p 
      also lee seunggi, well he’s not someone referred as idol, but he is someone who’d gained love by everyone. he’s kinda like “singer version” of yoo jaesuk for me.

  • Anonymous

    I want to be Hyunseung of BEAST!  Second choice: a member of Orange Caramel.

  • http://twitter.com/flickaddi Felicia Addison

    I agree with Fannie CL or Jia

  • Leejenny

    i would like to be in Miss A and be Jia but i would love it if i will be the 5th 2NE1 member, and make YG buy me a princess bed like Dara. haha. or atleast be one of YG’s dancers! i just want to be surrounded by YG people.

  • http://twitter.com/keytiisthebomb Cathe Sarmiento

    “Did YunJae really exist, how much porn did Changmin watch, how many girls did Yoochun go out with, and how did Junsu get that butt?”

    You’re not alone, Sister. Millions would want to be a member/part of the DBSK pre-breakup brotherhood.

    As for me, I’d love to be a member of JYJ and debunk the K-Pop industry. As for the girl group, I’ll go for Wonder Girls.

  • Anonymous

    Miss A: because they’re talented but a little underrated,  they have the freedom to sing and dance the way they want. It’s a little manufactured but what idol group isn’t. Also You’d be in the guidance of Jia and Fei who are AWESOME DANCERS.

    I also want to be in Wondergirls only because I love their consistency in their song choices, it’s very retro, it’s kitsch in a good way (Jewelry went too far with that concept) and I love yeeun and sunye. They’re AMAZING VOCALISTS

    Finally, I want to be in 2ne1 because they’re the epitome of fierce and they are totally standing up for women around the world. They’re not downtrodden, they’re just strong women and I would love to be a part of that!

    in terms of boybands: I want to be in Super Junior because if I love that they’re more talented in Comedy and Presenting than any other band atm. Hello, if i was half the suju member, I’d definitely try my hand at comedy if suju finishes.

  • kyasia

    ok, maybe i’m minority here..
    but i just want to be a part of any group in SM Ent.. either it’s boy or girl group..
    not a fan here, but i just want to know all their secret plus the “real” face of all their artist whoe seems so manufactured..
    i want to know, is key really a diva, is snsd eat more than 5 times, is amber really a tomboy, and is super junior really the unwanted child of SM Ent..
    also, i want to prove myself that if i became an idol from SM, can i endure the evil “slave contract and schedule” SM gave me..
    so, it seems so interisting to became a part of a entertaiment company like SM who had a lot of things going on inside of their company..

    note: if i have to choose, i also want to be in Shinee and becoming Taemin.. just because i want to received all the love from 4 hot, cute, stupid, and caring boys.. ;) *yes, shinee is my bias*

  • Bua

    miss A definitely. Because they are so classy, so powerful and beautiful. If I were to be a member of them, I would want to be Fei cuz she’s so beautiful and talented and very graceful on stage.

    As for the boy group, I would go for 2PM. I love their energy on stage and how natural they are. These boys seem to be so fun to hang out with. If u want to know YunJae exists, in my case I want to know if KhunWoo exists too lol

    • Anonymous

      I think I’d like to be a member of every group just to see if the shippings exist lol. 

  • Nana

    Super Junior. I’ll be the female maknae that is awesomely well rounded with the most charismatic personality ever and I’ll make all the fan girls jealous I hang with their oppas every day but they can’t hate me because I’m too nice and appealing #trollface

    • Anonymous

      lol that’s something that often happened in fanfic :p

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CI2NGOMLBNCWH5U4MKF57VJOHY Swaggerr

    CL all the wayyyyy; charisma x 10, multi-lingual, laidback

  • http://twitter.com/Dragonzsissi Sara

    I have the same opinion as Johnelle & Nabeela, I’d like to be in 2NE1^^ But I can’t say who, I’m between CL&Bom ;)

  • Andi

    I would love to be a member of Sunny Hill! I love the whole Co-Ed concept and I think adding another male to the group would even things out a bit.

  • Animasaurus

    Hmm… I would love to be a miss A member because there is a lovely down to earth real quality about them and they seem genuinely close to each other. It’s nice to see them getting love on this site because they are somewhat underappreciated which is a bit sad imo.

    I’d also love to be Dongwoo from Infinite because they have one of the best group dynamics and heartwarming bonds in kpop. It might mean working hard but to have 6 members who are like family with me all the time and being able to truly enjoy being apart of my band and having a good time together would be awesome… I chose him because I love his dancing and rapping, I want to experience that firsthand.

    I would’ve also said shinee, but there is a contrived/ behind the scenes quality about them I just can’t shake. It’s like we’re not getting the whole picture with them, and sometimes I sense that there is tension between the members off camera like Jonghyun with Minho/Onew… because otherwise I totally would’ve said golden heart, golden voice Onew because he is one of the most charming yet complicated people in Kpop… I’d love to get in his head but I’m not sure at what price tbh (I’m sure I’m thinking too deep but what ever lol).

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5JWLOENJVT24KU7ZTJZH3XOOXM Alexandra

    Id like to be in Miss A as well, they’re fierce and sassy, and they have good stylists. 
    Plus you get to hanging out with 2pm/2AM, kkab time with Jo kwon and staring at beastly abs FTW :)

  • jess1

    I’d want to be in 2NE1 for sure.
    Even though I don’t like all of the songs, the way they perform, the attitude, the clothes, their dorm, everything. Plus, I get to see Big Bang (yeah!) and maybe MBLAQ because of Dara. lol

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3MAXA4XUBRTP3H3WOOKIK3RNMY khady

    Like the majority of people who commented i would love to be anyone in YG! 
    If had to choose then i would be Bom and make TOP date me! ahahah ;)

  • xian

    i would really like to be part of any of these groups:
    2pm i know they would be the bridge for me to get closer with Miss A. i dont know why i got hook with Jia this much.
    Bigbang i really like the swag… they really like an icon of kpop, i mean the way they drive the stage…
    Beast  bacause im kinda addicted with their dancing… wanna learn em all…
    But i am a u-kiss fan..

    i know this is out of the topic but ladies i would want to meet someday aside from JIA are the rest of Miss A,  Bom, Ga-in, Hyuna(so HOT!), Bora and HYORIN( my ideal girl)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L3QTAJBP6QBZVM4RR6ZYPEO6UY hna

    I would love to be in JYP. I really really want to be a part of Miss A. their materials r good.n growing, better, everytime they release somethin..I love Jia (while Fei its…ah Fei.. u need to work on ur skill honey) n Suzy (while min,,ah min,,, u need to learn more on how to act as an idol…)

    not SM–> to slavery. kiddin XP its just their materials are tooooooo shallow while the packaging’s so wonderful (expensive). n the fact the always make repackaged album.its silly. also for a fact they did trial n error with their past artiste n then don’t care for every single artistes who’s not with them anymore

    not YG –> always fun fun fun but stupid (sorry), I mean they can’t or won’t hire artist from outside korea (maybe) cuz they hav no idea how to deal with the taxes or immigration thingy..they just got into market this year, too long. even with now they get into the market, from my pov their strong idealism will bring them down to some level (chilss YG fans out there), n the way they deal with their problems somehow, for me, its too stupid. n the fact for FAMILY as their motto, they can’t keep big mama!!!!!!! Big Mama 2nd album is d best!

    not PLEDIS –> the fact they fired bekah with ambiguous reason frustrate me. also their so called founder is from SM,so i guess u see it cominnot Core Contents Media –> the fact they produce SOMETHING silly n annoying like t-ara ..

    not c-jes (or JYJ’s company) –> cuz for whatever reason (its JYJ this JYJ that, its cuz SM this SM that.blah.) I think they who works there have no idea about entertainment business or running a business. trust me, I do think they don’t learn showbiz thoroughly before established an entertainment company. (see: how many shows in many countries cancelled, n the fact JYJ rarely seen on tv korea or even japan)

    yes, JYP –> for they have so many subsidiaries that actually success!!  big hit, j-tune, cube (now is independent corporation) ..n for the fact Park Jin Young is the owner. he’s awesome. very originals, n I love seeing k-pop under JYP, its westernized like any other k-pop but still have their originality even if its a tiny bit.*i’m business major so I’ll always try to find somethin from business pov :P n its showbiz… can’t really forget its an industry.INDUSTRY..hehe

  • ME

    Definitely Jia ‘miss A’. I fell hard for her since I saw her tango in ‘Without You’. JYP knows to produce lots good songs (at least for me, it’s personal taste :)) and genuinely cares for his employees. Should be a GREAT A+ for me. Imagine have to go to your office when you feel like the other way around. Working 24/7 with daily routine as rehearsal + dance/workout plus you have to finish your study, at least you have to keep your passion and have a company (and all colleagues) that support you a lot.

  • tvxqfangirl85

    I’m not one of those fangirls who fantasize about being an kpop idol. I know myself pretty well and I don’t take kindly to authority. So it would last all of two seconds, TOPS!
    But if I had to choose, it certainty wouldn’t be in SME. I just can not get with their system.
    Instead I would prefer either 2ne1 or Wonder Girls. Even Miss A.
    Since TVXQ are my obvious bias, I would use my status as an idol to get close to one of the members and marry him (I don’t care which member).

    This was fun girls. An interesting read^^

  • Anonymous

    Dude, EVERYONE is a better rapper than Minho. 
    Except me. I suck at rapping. In fact I’m pretty sure I would make Minho look like the god of rap and hence SM should hire me to be a part of Shinee.

  • Anonymous

    would have to be either shinee or dong bang shin ki. though i would love to be in a girl group, these two groups out of everyone i listen to consistantly record the kind of music i like: kpop as established by SM (i.e. HOT and SHINHWA). kpop to me is a mix of pop, rnb and hip hop. would love to be lead dancer, backing vocals and sub rapper (i.e. Key of Shinee). i guess i would have to choose shinee seeing as dbsk is done for, but definitely dbsk during their first three albums. but i wouldnt want to replace anyone. would just turn my five man group into a 6 man group